Sayville
Main Street dining, the ferries to Fire Island, and Sayville schools.
Welcome home to Sayville
Where Main Street
Meets the Bay.
Friendly, local real estate help from Nicole Rilling for buying or selling a home in Sayville, NY.
Your Sayville neighbor in real estate
A Local, Friendly Approach to Buying and Selling
Moving is a big deal, and it should feel easy. Nicole Rilling knows Sayville's streets, schools, and ferry schedules, and she treats every client like a neighbor. Whether you're buying your first home, selling the house you raised your family in, or moving here from out of state, she'll walk you through every step with a smile and a plan.
★★★★★ 20+ Google reviews
71 homes sold in 6 years
KW Realty Elite Top 25 Agent
Condo & co-op specialist
Meet Nicole
Call Nicole!
Let's Talk About Your Sayville Move
Call or text anytime. Nicole answers her own phone.
OfficeKeller Williams Realty Elite
96 E Main St, East Islip, NY
96 E Main St, East Islip, NY
Sayville and nearby
Surrounding Towns
Nicole helps buyers and sellers all along this stretch of the Great South Bay.
West Sayville
Quiet streets, marinas, and the Long Island Maritime Museum.
Bayport
Leafy blocks, bay beaches, and the Bayport-Blue Point schools.
Oakdale
Connetquot River State Park and easy access to Sunrise Highway.
Blue Point
A small bayside hamlet known for its oysters and village feel.
Patchogue & Bohemia
A lively downtown to the east and quick airport access to the north.
Buyers & sellers
Who Nicole Helps
First-time buyers
Every step explained in plain English, from pre-approval to keys.
Home sellers
Smart pricing, staging tips, and a plan to sell for top dollar.
Downsizing
Sell the family home and find your next place on your timeline.
Condos & co-ops
Board packages, building financials, and co-op rules, handled.
Out-of-state relocation
Video tours and honest local advice before you ever fly in.
A loved one's home
Patient, caring help for families and executors with estate sales.
Divorce home sales
A neutral, discreet process that works with both parties.
Free home value
Curious what your Sayville home is worth? Just ask.
Meet your Sayville realtor
Hi, I'm Nicole!
Nicole Rilling is a Licensed Real Estate Salesperson with Keller Williams Realty Elite, 96 E Main St, East Islip, NY, serving Sayville and the surrounding South Shore towns. She works with first-time buyers, home sellers, downsizers, condo and co-op buyers and sellers, out-of-state relocation clients, families selling the home of a loved one who has passed, and divorcing couples who need to sell. Nicole has closed 71 home sales in the past six years, including 7 closed sales so far in 2026 with an average sale price of $646,000. She holds Keller Williams Realty Elite Top 25 Agent status, is a Keller Williams capping agent year over year, and is part of The Yovino Team, a Top 5 team in the Massapequa office. She has 20+ five-star Google reviews. Call or text her at 516-884-8986 or email nicolerilling@kw.com.
- TitleLicensed Real Estate Salesperson
- BrokerageKeller Williams Realty Elite
- Office96 E Main St, East Islip, NY
- Reviews★★★★★ 20+ on Google
- Homes sold71 sales in the past 6 years
7 closed sales so far in 2026 - 2026 avg. price$646,000 average sale price
- RecognitionKeller Williams Realty Elite Top 25 Agent
The Yovino Team, Top 5 Team in the Massapequa office
Keller Williams capping agent, year over year
★★★★★
20+ Five-Star Reviews on Google
Sayville families trust Nicole to make moving simple. See what her clients say.
Read Nicole's Reviews